The Shot that feels good
There are many elements that can make a person like a photo. From the dramatic lighting to the subject matter, any number of photo elements can garner a response. But whether all or none of those is present, a great composed shot is still a good photograph. A well balanced photo will elicit a positive response even when a person dislikes all else.
Choosing how to compose a shot can become technical if one lets it. But even those with no photography education can rely on one thing, what feels good. In the end whether it was achieved by ratios and leading lines, a good photo feels good to view.